Objections to Proposition 401 and 402 – Is that possible?

On our Facebook page recently we were asked “Did anyone explain why they support or oppose the propositions?”  That is a great question! 

To our knowledge no one has provided an explanation on their decision to oppose the initiatives. Generally the rational to opposing them leans towards one of three possibilities.  Lets look at them?

The first is “We have a representative government.” It seems inconsistent that a candidate could ask for a citizen’s vote, then reject the notion of having citizen’s vote on an issue if it may conflict with their own agenda? From a citizen’s stand point, we cannot imagine somebody willingly giving up their authority to vote on an issue in a representative democracy.  At the local level we have the ability of requiring a “pure democratic” process on various issues.   Always on a General Obligation bond, and if the initiatives pass, on a Combination Bond or Lease Agreement.

Yes on 401 and 402
Great Question via Facebook

The second is “The elected officials have a better understanding.”  That may well be true at higher levels.  At the local level, Town Council members rely on the advice of Town Staff engaged full-time to understand the issues.  They also rely on outside vendors.  The advice comes through a “filter” of whoever is providing the advice.  The reality is, as a part-time position, the time constraints would be too significant to fully research and vet each issue.  Generally speaking, a good process results in a good outcome.  There are times when people may not like the outcome, but again, if there is good process, then the outcome is good.  The initiatives will force a “good process” as any future project that triggers them will need to have clear and concise arguments as to the benefits and to convince the general population on the merits of a project.  No smoke, no mirrors.  A good process ensuring the voice of the citizens and a “good outcome.”

Finally, there is concern that it will “Tie the hands of government.”  We are still undecided if that is a bad thing?  But let’s say it is for now?  Both have “triggers.”   That is they are not “triggered” and do not come into play on routine issues.

The Lease Initiative, 401, has numerous “carve outs.”   For example, communication(s) easements, utility easements, airport commission leases, and intergovernmental agency agreements are exempt from being “triggered.”  The initiative is only triggered on leases of three years or more OUTSIDE of the predefined carve outs for public land.

The Debt Initiative, 402 is a bit more complex.  That is only triggered if there is a guarantee of funding via the general fund and the debt is over $1,000,000.00.  A pure “Revenue Bond” at any amount could still be issued without a general vote.  This link, or the one below explains the debt issue in more detail.  So what about other forms of debt?  Say the fire department needs a 1.2 million truck.  Simple, put $200,001.00 as a down payment, and the initiative is not “triggered.”  Short term loan of 1.5 million?  Again, the obvious work around is two loans, each below the one million trigger.

As to why candidates support them?

Maybe because the candidates who support them are the same candidates who value citizen’s input and wish for a transparent process?

 

Again, a great question!  Thank you for asking Mr. Collins!

 

The link below explains the debt issue in a bit more detail.

Conjecture, Speculation, Potential for Abuse? Voters will decide.

 

  • If you disagree with the government overriding the citizens' valid vote...

     

    Please donate!

    We make donations easy. 

     

    If you want to mail a check, our mailing address is 1422 N. Sunrise Court, Payson, AZ  85541.  Or, if you prefer, contact us by phone, and we can arrange a pickup.  480  (dash - stop bots) 628 (dash bots) 6818.  If you want to donate online, we use Crowd Pac.

     

    We appreciate the support. 

     

     

     The committee is legally obligated to collect demographic and employment information. We are required to collect information on contributions of $200.00 or more. 

  • Recent Updates

    • Motions and BriefsAn Answering Brief on Transparent Payson Appeal
      The Town has filed an answering brief to the appeal. The entire brief on Transparent Payson’s appeal is below in .pdf. The Town maintains that the Voter Protection Act does not apply to general-law towns. Based on the totality of the record and […]
    • Payson RFR FOIA Records Request.Payson has nuclear launch codes. An RFR/FOIA update
      That is likely not true; Payson does not have nuclear launch codes.  But it must be something.  On March 7th, we requested documents under a request for records (RFR), commonly called a FOIA request.  We have reviewed some that should be in the […]
    • Words Matter – Playing by the Rules
      Resolution 3423 was passed, stopping the $70m bond issuance.  There was limited discussion before the passage.  The entire three-hour thirty-minute video may be found on the Town of Payson website.  To save you some pain, we have taken excerpts.  […]
    • Payson Bond deal is dead.Is the $70m bond deal dead? A host of updates.
      Things are happening.  As always, full .pdf support is below.  We received a very generous donation from a local community member.  He also has issues with the Town and its practices.  Please support us if you can. The records request (RFR in […]
    • Catch-22 Payson StyleCatch-22 Payson Style
      Generally, all court filings are public records; there are some exceptions for domestic matters.  In Arizona, the actual documents can be accessed via the eAccess portal.  Pay a small fee and get a copy of the document.  S-0400-CV-202400271, Rose […]
    • Payson School District continuation overide.Only a Penny – The Payson School Override
      “Only” is a word that is a matter of perspective.  When the sales tax increased by 1%, people in favor said it was “only a penny.”  People who buy groceries know that pennies add to dollars.  In this post, we outlined that 1% […]
  • A Healthy Government Does NOT Suppress Free Speech.

     

     

    Click the picture of silence above to learn more.

  • Contact Us.

     

    If you have questions or comments, please feel free to contact us. Stay informed on upcoming meetings, events, and progress. No worries; we never sell or distribute your information. We send occasional emails, always on point. Please click the icon below to send us an email.

    Email Us.

    Thank you!

  • Learn why these issues are essential.

     

     

    Act Up!

    Click the "ACT UP" picture to learn more.

  • A History of Transparent Payson

    Where it started, and where we are now. 

     A history of Transparent Payson

    We have been involved in voters' rights since 2018.

     

      Click the History picture above to learn more.

  • Join us on Facebook:

    Facebook Logo

    Click the Fcebook icon.