They Have But One Duty

 

Payson has such a wealth of knowledge in the community.  We first realized that six years ago as we drafted and circulated the petitions, known as Propositions 401 and 402.  This pool of knowledge undoubtedly reflects the median age, which is 59.8 years old.

There are many intelligent people and so much life experience to draw from.  As a community, we should embrace that remarkable resource.  Transparent Payson, as a group, has learned so much from various people with unique backgrounds.  We welcome and appreciate their input; it is invaluable.  As a recent example, a supporter pointed out that the Town Council may have violated an Arizona Supreme Court ruling from 1934 in Button v. Nevin, 44 Ariz. 247.  The Council may have also violated Chapter 2, Section 4 of the Public Officers Employee Handbook.

Here is the snapshot version of that case from the handbook.

2.4 Duties and Responsibilities of Public Officers.
Public officers must impartially execute all laws and rules for which they are responsible.  The Arizona Supreme Court stated as follows in Button v. Nevin, 44 Ariz. 247, 257, 36 P.2d 568, 571 (1934):

“Public officials may not violate the plain terms of a statute because in their opinion better results will be attained by doing so. They have but one duty, and that is to enforce the law as it is written, and, if the effect of their action is disastrous, the responsibility is upon the Legislature and not upon them.”

 

“They have but one duty.”  That is a powerful statement.

 

One duty.  Does a repeal of the voters’ will reflect that duty?   We discussed this concern previously.  Town Council, arguing against the validity of the vote or the election, would not seem to embody “the power to be heard” in a democracy.  Does Town Legal, Mr. Paladini, or the Town Manager, Mr. Smith, have to abide by that duty?  Did Mr. Paladini adhere to that duty when he argued for the purported repeal to the Town Council?  Did Mr. Smith do so when he outlined the Town’s position in a depositionThe voters can decide.

You can find the full case text in the .pdf below.  The case has various citations; if you are inclined, you can learn more here.  We also attach a full copy of the Public Officers Employee Handbook in .pdf below.

Co-plaintiff Nichols has elected to withdraw from the suit.  The process of litigation on any issue is not for everybody.  The portion of the suit that the co-plaintiff was involved in was based on using an “emergency ordinance” that precluded a referendum on the Council vote.  All elements of the use of the emergency declaration have been removed.  We are now left with only the issues of the purported repeal.

An amended complaint has been filed with the court.  As these are public records, we have attached a full copy of the amended complaint in .pdf below.  The hearing will likely be scheduled in mid-September.  We understand that the Judge is out of Saint Johns; the hearing will be in Payson.  Once scheduled, we will get the details out.

We welcome YOUR involvement in this process.  Dare we say, support the cause.

We appreciate your continued support.

 

Chapter 2, Section 4 of the Public Officers Employee Handbook

082623 agency_handbook_chapter_2

Button v. Nevin, 44 Ariz. 247

082623 Button v. Nevin

First Amended Verified Complaint for Special Action/Injunctive Relief

082423 Stipulation and summary for upload

 

  • Support the effort

    Donate HERE!

     The committee is legally obligated to collect demographic and employment information.

  • Recent Updates

    • Time to vote! Let the incumbents know what you think.
      Transparent Payson has become a voting rights group in defense of Propositions 401 and 402. Voting can be divided into many categories: rights, the consent of the governed, collective wisdom, and a host of various reasons, each equally compelling. […]
    • An Award for Affordable Housing
      We recently discussed the need for affordable housing in Payson.  Three proposals were made for federal tax credits to enable housing.  The Arizona Department of Housing award was made to Green Valley II of Payson, LLC, headed by Jacob Swartwood. […]
    • The Initial Verdict Is In
      We are not surprised at the outcome. The Court Order/ verdict is attached in its entirety below as a PDF. The potential next step is an appeal. The Board will meet with Counsel to discuss this. Any potential appeal relies on donations.  It cannot be […]
    • Private gain at the public trough – you decide.
      There has been significant discussion of late about affordable housing in Payson.  On April 10th, the Town of Payson declared a housing emergency via Resolution 3376.  There was also a housing proclamation on that date.  The issue is not unique to […]
    • Trial update and appearance on KMOG
      The trial was completed last Friday, the 19th.  Transparent Payson has always viewed the matter as a question of law, which results in a slightly different trial than many may be familiar with in a civil setting. There was no discovery, no experts, […]
    • Trial is scheduled for April 19th at 1:30
      We can use your continued support.  Please donate. To finance the Town’s list of projects Town Council increased the TPT/Sales tax.  That tax becomes effective on May 1st.  The rate will be 10.48%.  Some people tithe.  The TPT/ Sales tax rate […]
  • A Healthy Government Does NOT Suppress Free Speech.

     

     

    Click the picture or here to learn more.

  • A History of Transparent Payson

     

    Where it started, and where we are now. 

     A history of Transparent Payson

     

    We have been involved in voters' rights since 2018.

    Click the picture or here to learn more.

  • Join us on Facebook:

    Facebook Logo

    Click the icon or here.

  • Learn why these issues are important.

     

     

    Act Up!

    Click the picture or here to learn more.

  • Contact Us.

     

    Questions or comments, please feel free to contact us.  Stay informed on upcoming meetings, events, and progress. No worries, we never sell or distribute your information. About one email a week, sometimes more, but always on point. Please visit our "Contact Us" or click the icon below to send us an email.

    Email Us.

    Thank you!